top of page

CofC's Civility Initiative dares to disagree

brickleyba
13 hours ago
6 min read

by Bridget Brickley

It was a typical Saturday night for College of Charleston senior Elliot Green — a pregame, a walk on King Street to a birthday party, and a conversation starting “bit” to keep herself entertained along the way. 


“F*** Donald Trump!” she bantered to strangers passing by the bar, extending her hand out for a fist bump. 


That night, however, Green’s bid for a fist bump was met with two fists to the face, knocking her out cold for three minutes.


“There was just blood everywhere,” she recalled. “One minute I was awake, and I was hearing what people were saying had happened — because I didn’t actually know.”

What she began to understand was that a man who heard her conversation starter was not entertained – and decided to punch her because of it.


“I shouldn’t have been doing that bit in this political climate in general,” she admitted, “but also, I shouldn’t have been met with violence for it.”


Stories like hers are not uncommon in the media these days, with political violence and polarization at the center of it all.


A January 2026 PRRI survey found that 67% of Americans believe political leaders’ failure to condemn violent rhetoric contributes significantly to violence in society, while 6% said physically attacking a political opponent could be justified in pursuit of political goals. 

According to these CofC students, this hostility is tied to a broader problem: the way political conflict is portrayed and amplified by the media.


“I think that the way the news frames things is always very accusatory of both sides,” said finance major Damon Greenan, “it paints both sides out to be drastically more radical than they actually are.”


Audrey Rosen, a sociology major at The College, described a similar experience with the media. 


“Every time you open any news outlet, they’re gonna be like, ‘The Democrats did this today’ and ‘the MAGA people are doing this.’ They’re encouraging division by using labels like that,” she said. “It’s like an era of hate. Everyone just loves to hate. It sucks.”


Both students believe that catered media algorithms play a role in these portrayals, reinforcing bias and furthering division.


“I think algorithms are really strong and really targeted,” Greenan explained. “You’re going to hear exactly what you want to hear and see exactly what you want to see.”


Rosen added that the algorithm also keeps people in their bias bubbles.


“The more you click on certain things, the more that they appear, and then you think that everyone’s on your side or not on your side,”  she said.


These algorithms lead students to another problem – with such radical and contradictory messaging, how do they know what the truth is?


“I’m consuming a lot of misinformation, and now I think it’s true because there’s so much of it.” Rosen admitted.


Greenan believes that nothing “feels true” because of that.


“You can say something and really feel passionate about it, but your sources could be totally wrong,” he said.


According to Greenan, skepticism in sources breeds self-doubt, silencing people before they speak.


“Your source could have been some random Instagram post you saw that you took a little too seriously,” Greenan explained. “I think people are worried about the shame of that.”


But embarrassment is only one catalyst behind a widespread, underreported trend: Americans opting out of disagreement altogether.


While media headlines scream conflict, CofC classrooms offer a very different reality: total silence and deliberate conflict avoidance.


“I’ve never really witnessed any issues in conversation on campus," Greenan explained about political debates getting personal. “But I witnessed a lot of people who just weren’t engaged or didn’t feel like they had space to speak.”

That reluctance is not unique to CofC.


 A 2024 Knight Foundation and Ipsos survey found that 69% of college students self-censor on at least one commonly discussed campus topic, while only 60% said they felt comfortable sharing their opinions during in-person class discussions.


Rosen, too, admits to treading carefully when political topics surface during class.


“I don't want to start a conflict, because you never know what could be sensitive to somebody,” she explained. “I just like to move in silence.”


CofC communication professor Mike Lee, director of the Civility Initiative at The College, sees this reluctance to debate as a widespread cultural problem.


“There’s so many reasons, including media and social media, why Americans are struggling to connect with one another and to have healthy conflict with one another.”


That reluctance isn’t limited to politics—Lee points out it now infects everyday conversations.


“Polls show when Americans are asked to have a difficult conversation with somebody they disagree with, their anticipation of negativity is way worse than their experience of the conversation itself.”


Like his students, Lee traces this hesitation back to a world tailored specifically to the individual.


He pointed to the modern landscape, where everyday experiences are relentlessly curated for the individual.


“I live in a world where I don’t have to listen to the radio and just listen to whatever music the radio station designs for me,” he described. “I can customize my playlist. I can customize my Instagram algorithm.” 


To Lee, however, ultimate personalization is just a precursor to total isolation.

“The more I can kind of withdraw and separate from the messiness of public life and live in this world where everything is designed for me and by me,” Lee said,  “the more discomfort we experience around disagreement, because I can customize my whole life to be consistent with what I already believe and feel.”

The result is a subtle withdrawal from real-world human contact.


“We just have less and less contact every day,” he said. “I read less stories. I watch less reels about people who are different from me. And then when I do, from that distance, I watch them with my already-established opinions, and my opinions aren’t being shaken.”


As that gap widens, disagreement can easily morph into the demonization of difference. 


“The further I distance myself from you the easier it is to demonize you from afar. And then the more I demonize you from afar, the harder it is for me to approach conflict with you when it’s time.”


Yet despite the natural instinct to pull away, Lee argues that avoiding conflict is both impossible and counterproductive.


“Disagreement is inevitable, and so it’s a fantasy that we can avoid it," says Lee, “so the question is not how much we can avoid it, but how we can use it to our advantage?”


He illustrates the double-edged nature of disagreement with a simple comparison.


“Conflict is like fire.” he explained, “it’s a tool, and it can really help our relationships and help us make better decisions and heat our house, or, it can certainly burn it down.” 


When done correctly, Lee says that having difficult conversations “looks like more engagement, more talking to strangers, more discourse about things that we otherwise wouldn’t talk about.”


In an increasingly isolated world, overcoming our fear of conflict starts with a willingness to simply speak up.


“The spiral of silence is very real, and we should be talking about issues,” Rosen said, “And even if we can't come to a positive conclusion, at least we talked about it.”


When people withhold their opinions, Greenan argues, we lose something vital: a genuine understanding of where others stand.


 “I think we’re losing a lot of empathy for each other,” Greenan said. “We need to be able to understand those differences and walk away from the conversation with respect for each other.” 


Lee has seen firsthand what happens when people actively bridge those divides through the Civility Initiative.


“Americans are experiencing a real loneliness crisis, and so there’s a real hunger for connection," Lee explained. “The Civility Initiative has been really fortunate to find ways to help people in this community and people on this campus connect with one another when they might not have otherwise connected.”


That connection often yields deeply emotional results, with attendees leaving events visually moved.


“People came up in tears, saying that they hadn’t really felt hope for the country or for the city in a long time," Lee said, "and they felt it in that room.”


Reflecting on the initiative’s impact, Lee said the main takeaway has been seeing people rediscover hope “in a world that, to many people, can seem very divided and hopeless.'”


While avoiding and stigmatizing debate may not cause bloody noses, it’s not healthy either, says Rosen.  


“Silence is violence."

Comments


bottom of page