top of page

How local is Charleston’s 'local' seafood? Depends.

hansonoa
13 hours ago
4 min read


By Ollie Hanson

On a chalkboard behind the bar at Bowen’s Island Restaurant, the seafood specials change depending on what is available.


Oysters, shrimp and “fresh catch” make their way onto plates as customers look out over the same marshes and waterways where some of that seafood originated.


But in Charleston, a city where “local seafood” appears across menus, markets and restaurants, local does not always mean caught in the harbor.


Sometimes it means a mile down the creek, and sometimes it means Georgia, North Carolina or even farther.


For the people actually buying and selling seafood in Charleston, where a fish comes from depends on the species, season, weather, availability and the relationships they have built with fishermen and suppliers.


At CudaCo., owner Shawn Brian sees the term “local” as more regional than literal.

“A fish doesn’t have a physical address,” Brian said.


Depending on the species and what fishermen are able to catch, seafood sold in Charleston can come from throughout the Southeast while still being considered local.


“Under the guidelines of what is local, you could be getting fish from Georgia, Florida, and North Carolina, and that’s all considered local,” Brian said.


That means sourcing seafood is not as simple as restaurants deciding they only want fish caught in Charleston waters.


At Bowen’s Island Restaurant, however, some seafood travels a much shorter distance.


“All the oysters are harvested within a mile or two of Bowen’s Island,” owner Robert Barber said.


Shrimp can be a different story.


“We’ve always done either local or regional shrimp,” Barber said, explaining that the restaurant currently has a source in Georgia.


For Barber, the goal is not necessarily for every piece of seafood to come directly from Charleston waters, but to source it as close to home as possible.


“If you present yourself as local seafood, you want to get as local as you can get it,” Barber said.


Chubby Fish takes a similar local approach, but chef Devon Knight said the restaurant’s sourcing is driven heavily by what fishermen are actually able to bring in.


“Most, if not all, of our fishermen go to sleep in South or North Carolina every night,” Knight said.


Instead of choosing a specific fish first and finding someone who can supply it, the restaurant often has to work in the opposite direction.


What comes out of the water helps determine what ends up on the menu, meaning the species of fish available can change with the season, weather and catch.


Knight said this makes planning a seafood menu different from planning around ingredients that are easier to predict.


The restaurant receives whole fish and breaks them down in-house, keeping the process between the fisherman and the kitchen much shorter.


But not every Charleston restaurant builds its seafood program around what can be caught nearby.


At KYN, Peter Marcus described a sourcing process that can stretch thousands of miles from Charleston to fish markets in Japan.


The restaurant works with a supplier there, telling them what types of fish and quality they are looking for based on what they plan to serve.


Fish, including tuna, can then be selected in Japan and flown to the United States before eventually reaching the restaurant in Charleston.


Marcus explained that much of KYN’s process has come from learning from people in Japan and figuring out how to bring those same standards and techniques back to Charleston.


At the same time, KYN still works with smaller local suppliers when the right seafood is available nearby.


The differences between several local seafood spots shows just how complicated the word “local” can become.


For Bowen’s Island, an oyster can come from just a mile or two away, though oysters served elsewhere in the Lowcountry can travel from farther


At CudaCo., local can stretch across state lines, depending on the species and season.

KYN will allow the search for a specific fish to stretch all the way to Japan.


Local is tied less to an exact distance and more to working directly with fishermen throughout South and North Carolina for Chubby Fish chefs.


Behind each approach are relationships with the people who catch, sell and move seafood.


Brian described the seafood business as an “old school industry,” where trust is built through hard work and relationships over time.


“One of the biggest components is building relationships,” Brian said.


Those relationships become especially important in an industry where very little is guaranteed.


At Chubby Fish, that relationship can be direct enough that fishermen come into the restaurant during dinner service with their catch.


That leaves Knight and the kitchen working with what is available rather than expecting fishermen to produce a specific fish just because it is on the menu.


Knight explained that this is also why the restaurant can plan more around seasonal produce while staying flexible about exactly which fish will accompany it.


Boats break down, weather changes, regulations affect what can be caught and fishermen depend on what they are able to bring in.


Another challenge is finding younger people willing to enter an industry with that much uncertainty.


“Problem is getting young people to go on boats,” Brian said.


For restaurants and markets, those challenges eventually affect what seafood is available and how far they have to go to get it.


The phrase “local seafood” may sound simple on a menu, but the path from the water to a Charleston restaurant rarely is.


It can begin on an oyster bed a mile away, on a shrimp boat in Georgia or even in a fish market thousands of miles away in Japan.


In Charleston, how local seafood really is depends on what is being served, what is available and the people responsible for getting it from the water to the plate.


For Knight, working with what is available nearby is also part of what being a chef is supposed to mean.


“As a restaurant and a chef, it’s your duty to do the things you do with the things around you,” Knight said. “Historically, the precedent is that a chef does what he can with what is around him.


And Knight believes that’s the way it should always be.


“So that’s kind of our whole thing,” Knight said. “All of our vegetables come from around here, all of our fish come from around here.”



header.all-comments


bottom of page