top of page

Social media helps shape how Charleston businesses thrive

Writer: Sierra Ethington
Sierra Ethington
10 minutes ago
5 min read

By Sierra Ethington

A few tiny plastic ducks helped turn a Charleston coffee shop into a viral destination, but owner Nichole Tupas learned that going viral does not guarantee customers will keep coming back. 


Tupas, owner of Harlow and Pearl, had ordered what she thought was a pack of rubber ducks. 


Instead, 200 tiny plastic ducks showed up. Not knowing what to do with them, she started to give them out with the coffee. 


When a friend later posted a photo of Tupas’ Lucky Charms matcha with a duck sitting on top, customers began lining up outside the cafe asking for the drink, and a duck!


“Everybody was asking for this matcha, this latte that has the blue cold foam and the Lucky Charms, and everybody wanted it,” Tupas said. “They were like, ‘We’re here for the little duck.”


The post helped make it one of Tupas’ best summers in business, but the attention did not last forever. 


“When they [Lindsay and Emma] came in and did the video for us, they went super viral, and everyone was able to find us, and that was probably one of the best summers I’ve ever had in business,” Tupas said.


The experience reflects a shift in how people discover restaurants and coffee shops, as social media increasingly puts food destinations in front of potential customers before they ever walk through the door. 


A 2024 TouchBistro survey of more than 1,500 U.S. diners found that 52% of Gen Z diners have decided to try a new restaurant based entirely on positive feedback on social media, while 32% said they had chosen a new restaurant based entirely on an influencer recommendation. 


Customers are paying attention


For Charleston residents, that online discovery can happen regularly. 


Malerie Hinson, who lives and works in Charleston, said she uses social media to decide where to eat at least once a week. 


She remembers visiting The Obstinate Daughter after seeing it on social media and said the restaurant ended up living up to the attention it received online. 


“I really liked it,” Hinson said. 


Hannah Gulbronson, a College of Charleston student and life-long Charleston resident, also said she uses social media to decide where to eat or get coffee at least once a week. 


For Gulbronson, social media can introduce her to restaurants she might not otherwise visit, including Paris Baguette, where she ordered popular items such as pastries and an egg salad sandwich. 


When the feed doesn't match the food

But discovering a restaurant online does not necessarily mean the experience will match what social media users saw on their screens. 


Gulbronson said she had a different experience at Allora, a coastal Italian restaurant in downtown Charleston. After seeing it all over her social media, she decided to try the new restaurant. 


“I feel like Allora is really cute, and the food looks good, but it doesn't taste that great,” Gulbronson said. 


The bigger appeal was the restaurant’s appearance.


“I didn’t even think it was bad. It was just not great food, but I don’t think people go there for the food,” Gulbronson said. “It’s for the vibes.” 


That disconnect can make social media both a marketing tool and a source of expectations that businesses have to meet once customers arrive. 


A 2024 Toast survey of 850 adults who use social media at least once a week found that 62% sometimes check a restaurant's social media before deciding whether to dine there, while 84% said they prefer seeing photos of the food and drinks on the restaurant’s social media page. 


Hinson said she pays attention to what other diners say online, especially when those comments are negative. 


"Yeah. Negative comments, I believe them,” Hinson said. “I feel like it takes a lot to comment on something negative.”


For Tupas, social media can also work in the opposite direction, giving businesses a way to see how customers react after a product has already been introduced. 


When Harlow and Pearl first released its birthday cake latte, customers criticized the way the drink looked after all the components were mixed together. 


“They were right,” Tupas said. “It did look really gross.” 


The business changed the drink's presentation based on that feedback. 


“So we completely changed the way we made the latte and made it more aesthetic, and we made it even more delicious too,” she added. 


That kind of feedback has become part of how Tupas uses social media, even though she said she does not typically create drinks simply because they are trending. 


“I don’t like doing what other people are doing,” Tupas said. “But typically no. We do our own thing.” 


For Charleston businesses, standing out can be especially important in an oversaturated food and beverage market. 


Tupas said the number of coffee shops in the Charleston area makes it necessary for Harlow and Pearl to offer more than just a visually appealing drink. 


“So while, yes, social media brings people in, it’s the attention to detail and just caring about others and creating a safe and comfortable space for everyone [that] kind of brings people back,” Tupas said. 


Going viral, however, is not always predictable. 


Tupas remembered another time when she thought a social media post featuring actress Madison Bailey would bring a surge of

customers to the shop. 


“Once we post this, we’re gonna be famous,” Tupas remembered thinking. 

Instead, it was one of the slowest weeks the business had experienced. 


“Social media is so…” Tupas said, looking for a description.


Hit or miss?


“Yeah, yeah. It’s really hit or miss,” she said. 


Views don't always translate to sales


That uncertainty is part of what separates social media visibility from lasting success. 


After the Lucky Charms matcha went viral, Harlow and Pearl continued creating drinks that attracted attention online, including birthday cake and banana pudding lattes. 


But after the business moved from its Mount Pleasant location to downtown Charleston, Tupas said the online attention did not translate into sales. 


“Unless I'm posting about having birthday cake or banana pudding [lattes], typically, it’s been pretty slow here, to be honest with you,” Tupas said. “So, basically, our population on social media is not translating to sales right now at this moment.” 


For diners, the same platforms that introduce them to new destinations also give them a way to decide whether their destination was worth the visit. 


Hinson and Gulbronson have both encountered local restaurants that did not live up to their online hype. 


But sometimes a social media push is a pleasant surprise. Swank, a dessert shop in Summerville, was just such a place for Gulbronson. 


“Oh, no, that was fucking amazing,” Gulbronson said. “I thought it was going to be good, and it was.” 


What brings customers back


For Tupas, those in-person experiences ultimately matter more than the number of views or likes a post receives. 


“I don’t think that our social media alone is bringing us lasting customers,” Tupas said. “I think our customer service does that.” 


In a city where coffee shops can become a destination because of one drink, one video, or even one tiny plastic duck, social media may be what gets customers through the door. 


But Tupas said what happens once they arrive is what gives them a reason to return. 


“Treating people like they’re part of our family and like we’ve been lifelong friends, you know, that also brings people back.”

Comments


bottom of page